Cross Platform Interchange - No Escalator Rides ☹

In a metro system with multiple lines, usually a person transfers from one line to another to reach their destination. A station where one can transfer is called an interchange. In an interchange, normally the lines are stacked one above the other. This means one must use stairs, escalators or lifts to interchange between lines.

A cross-platform Interchange ( CPI ) is a type of interchange, where changing from one line to another means just walking across the same platform and does not require usage of stairs, escalators, or lifts.

When two lines cross each other,  there is a maximum of 8 possible ways to transfer between lines. I will look at some interesting station designs which enable easy cross-platform interchange

Island platforms play an important role in enabling CPI.

Full CPI or Paired stacked-island cross-platform

This supports all possible interchange movements. This requires two stations. Each Station has two island platforms stacked one above the other.

This supports all possible interchange movements. This requires two stations. Each Station has two island platforms stacked one above the other.  

If you notice, it is possible to continue in any direction on the other line with this set of interchanges, just by walking across the platform at either station.

City Hall and Raffles Place which serve the red and green lines on the Singapore MRT ( Mass Rapid Transit )are an example of this.

First this is like “uh! They have two platform Interchanges in row.” But this is not the case. Basically, if you want to continue in the same direction, you transfer at one station and if you want to head in a different direction, you transfer at another.

The track layout is arranged in a way that there are two levels and train swaps levels when going from one station to another. This is also how direction changing is possible.  

Single Station Same Level cross-platform interchange

In this type, there are three island platforms on the same station, and they support 6 of the 8 possible transfers. It is obvious that that the trains have doors on both sides to make use of this approach.




This is the most common CPI that is used across the world. An example of this is the Fulton Street Station on the New York City Subway

 


Another example of this can be found in London Underground, where there are two Island platforms in a single station, instead of three.  This reduces the number of CPIs supported to only 4 of the possible 8 transfers.

Single Station Stacked Platform Interchange

In this case, there are two island platforms, stacked one above the other in a single station. This arrangement supports 4 of the possible 8 transfers.  Lai King Station on Hong Kong MTR (Mass Transit Railway, not Mavalli Tiffin Room) is an example of this.


In this case,  the dominant direction of each line is present  in each of the island platforms. This allows people to transfer to and from dominant direction easily.  


 Another example of this is Taipei metro, which has three stations with Stacked Island platforms on each of them. This serves three lines, namely Red, Green and Yellow lines.

 


Please note there there are around 66 cities with CPIs in the world of which I’ve covered only a few and of the 66 CPIs 14 are in China. Not too surprising for me. ( 41 of 204 Metro systems are in China ) anyway, see you later.

Unfortunately, none of them are in India. Before you start questioning me,  the mainline railway platforms in India,  which have two tracks in between two island platforms are considered as CPI.

Hopefully this is the last post, where I bore your about metro trains.

Thank-you 

Comments

  1. பாஸ்கி25 April 2022 at 19:20

    Nice

    ReplyDelete
  2. Raghavan Subramaniyan26 April 2022 at 04:47

    I found this very interesting. Didn't know that there could be so many variations. The first 3 are for 2 line interchange, and the last one is for 3. I guess 4 line interchange must be super complicated (does it exist?). Next time I travel in metros abroad, I'll try and pay attention.
    So India does not have CPIs in their metros. To see this positively, people get more exercise moving up and down to change train lines ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Gutubaran26 April 2022 at 08:50

    I remember Moscow has has quad line interchange and i think beijing and new York as well as Seoul have them

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rail Gauges

Image
When you go on a train you may wonder how the train stays firmly on the rails. It does so because the inner distance between 2 rails is kept the same through out the track with millimeter accuracy. This inner distance is called Rail Gauge. It also determines the size of your train coach / car.     There are quite a few rail gauges out there, but I’m going to focus on the four main ones. (Everything seems to have four main ones, like Vedas, directions, oceans etc.) Indian Gauge or Broad Gauge – 1676 mm   Broad gauge is the most commonly used gauge in India and is also the widest gauge. It is also called as Provincial , Portland , or Texas gauge in North America, Trocha Ancha (which is Spanish for Broad Gauge ) in Argentina. It is also used in Pakistan, western Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Argentina, Chile and BART metro in San Francisco. Standard Gauge – 1435 mm Standard Gauge is the oldest and most commonly used gauge in the world.   In India, it is used only ...
Read more

Why Metro Rail?

  There are quite a few modes of rapid transit out there like trams, buses, metros, suburban rail etc. In India a little more than a dozen cities have Metros, including Mumbai, Chennai, Bengaluru, Delhi and many more. But why are cities choosing metros? Why not trams or suburban rail? Let’s talk about that.   Now you want to know why cities are choosing metros for their rapid transit, right? Cities choose metros mainly to move people from one part of the city to another, unlike say suburban rail which moves people from the outside to the inside of a city and vice versa. Now, you may think “why are cities building expensive metros instead of much more cheaper trams of Buses?” there are 2 main reasons:   1) Capacity 2) Traffic Let me explain.   C apacity is the most important reason cities build metros.   Metros  can carry huge swaths of people and still operate every 2 or 3 minutes. Trams, on the other hand  have only about 3/4s the capacity of a metro....
Read more

High Speed Rail

Image
  High speed rail (or HSR) is a railway network in which a train can operate at high speeds, typically defined as greater than 200 KMPH or 120 MPH. Tokaido Shinkansen in Japan was first HSR line in the world. It started in 1960s. Ever since then many countries have developed their own HSR networks Some known ones are France's TGV, Germany's ICE, Spain's Renfe and China's CRH. India is currently building it’s own HSR line between Ahmedabad and Mumbai which the help of Japan. It is expected to open in 2028. The title of the fastest train in the world was achieved by the Chuo Shinkansen on a trail run between Tokyo and Osaka reaching a top speed of 600KMPH!!. The fastest commercially running train currently is the Shanghai maglev in china which runs at 420 KMPH.   Now how many think why build HSR when planes are there. There are 3 main reasons-     Travel time When you are travelling on a short distance let's say Chennai to Bengaluru, winch is around 375K...
Read more